Download Free Sample
Order New Solution
With Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice and Captain America: Civil War both concentrating on the conflict between their respective primary heroes, 2016 was the year that the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the DC Extended Universe most overtly competed on the big screen. However, even if both films were eagerly anticipated, the first one disappointed die-hard fans more than it satisfied the general public. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice foreshadowed numerous issues for the DCEU despite introducing the superbly cast Batman and Wonder Woman, bringing the famous DC trio together in live-action for the first time, and including breath-taking scenes like Batman's warehouse battle and Superman's trial. The Justice League was hastily assembled in Zack Snyder's Man of Steel sequel, and Superman was murdered off during his second outing (Hughes, 2016). Most crucially, though, the rivalry between the two main characters was not satisfactorily resolved in Batman v. Superman. This doesn't necessarily imply that Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice was a subpar film. Captain America and Iron Man’s conflict, however, had a far more appropriate conclusion in Captain America: Civil War. Additionally, Bucky Barnes and Black Panther now have a cogent quarrel because to the Civil War (Schilling, 2016).
"Batman vs. Superman" is a disjointed, clumsy film that exudes an undeserved arrogance. When it comes to the plot, Batman's entrance in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice couldn't have been better, yet the rest of the film unfortunately wastes this strong start. In addition to the fact that his business and friends were impacted, Bruce Wayne's efforts to save bystanders while Superman was battling Zod also served to justify his goals for the remainder of the film. He had also personally experienced the calamity. The involvement of Lex Luthor Jr., who threatens Superman into battling Batman and gives Batman Kryptonite, complicates the struggle. Superman is painstakingly hesitant to explain to Batman what is truly going on, letting him take the initiative with Kryptonite instead of using his nearly limitless strength to try to remedy the issue as fast as possible (Mendelson, 2016).
Beyond Batman and Superman's annoying lack of communication, the movie's most absurd scene is the conclusion of their fight. Batman finally agrees to spare Superman when he begs him to "rescue Martha," the name of both heroes' moms. Superman had no justification for calling his mother by her name, much less at that precise time. And although it seems sense that Batman would be alarmed by that name, it is improbable that a vicious and experienced vigilante who has fought more battles than any other live-action Batman would be so quickly disarmed by such a common name.
However, the film Captain America: Civil War also has some problems. The absence of survival stakes for all of the Avengers, whose survival is almost guaranteed from the outset owing to their impending reappearance in subsequent MCU films, is perhaps the most frequent criticism the Russo Brothers' second MCU feature receives. Although the killing of Superman in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice was a calculated risk, Civil War was able to provide Iron Man and Captain America clear-cut outcomes to their conflict. Iron Man and Captain America, like Batman and Superman; swiftly abandon the fight between accountability and freedom. However, their divergent opinions on what to do with Bucky Barnes along with the repercussions of their personal conflict for their own lives do illustrate how they see the Sokovia Accords. After all was said and done, Captain America saved Iron Man's life but gave up his Avenger title and his shield. Iron Man misplaced his group. Without engaging them head-on, Zemo beat the Avengers. The Avengers split up, making the Earth totally open to an invasion by Thanos. Nobody reneged on their intentions. No one died, but towards the end, nobody remained the same (Schilling, 2016).
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice's second major hero conflict was a feature of Captain America: Civil War and both films might have easily made the same mistakes. Baron Zemo falsely accused Bucky Barnes of killing T'Chaka, which prompted T'Challa to seek retribution. The former Winter Soldier was finally welcomed in Wakanda by Black Panther, who was prepared to help him leave his terrible past behind. Bucky only revealed that he didn't murder his father once when battling as the Winter Soldier was being pursued by the Black Panther and tried to battle him to death. As the Winter Soldier, Bucky was unable to clear his name of a crime he really did not commit; therefore his main purpose was to escape the Avengers and the law. As a result, Bucky never expressed regret. Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice included every component necessary to create a compelling conflict and conclusion. In reality, it succeeds as a thrilling movie from start to finish. However, not just with its two major heroes but also with two of its supporting characters, Captain America: Civil War was successful in upholding its central tenet (Hughes, 2016).
While Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice's $166.1 million opening weekend was significantly greater than Captain America: Civil War's $179.14 million debut weekend, there is little question that the sequel to the huge hero vs. hero smack down will do far better both domestically and internationally. Because fans had already come to love these unique on-screen representations of Steve Rogers and Tony Stark, the idea of Captain America versus Iron Man was always a more compelling one than Batman V. Superman.
Batman v Superman's promotional efforts greatly emphasized the rivalry between the two eponymous characters, promising a colossal struggle between "God and man." Unfortunately, the real combat between Batman and Superman only lasts for 10 minutes and consists of of the two of them fighting one other; with brief breaks for Batman to hit Superman with a kryptonite trap. The biggest issue with this battle is that it scarcely has any bearing on how the movie turns out; Batman and Superman spar briefly before remaining close friends for the remainder of the movie until Superman is summarily killed in the last act. On the other hand, as Captain America and Iron Man prepare for their ultimate showdown, a dramatic wild card is introduced at the very last second, further altering the dynamics of their relationship. The camaraderie between the two characters seems drastically changed by the time they finish fighting one other, despite the fact that neither character is killed, which is a solid sign that this battle is essential to Civil War's overall plot (Hughes, 2016).
In that they exemplify the Boy Scout archetype and serve as the moral compass of their teams, Captain America and Superman are frequently contrasted. But their power sets couldn't be more dissimilar. Whereas, the Man of Steel, is a god - nearly immortal with Kryptonite which is officially considered as his only vulnerability. The Super Soldier, on the other extreme, is merely a human who just so happens to be trained in combat and has superhuman strength and endurance (he also ages slowly). In retrospect, he's best likened to Thor in the MCU because they both have a lot of power. The fact that Marvel Studios battled for years to make Odinson compelling supported Russos' argument.
Despite the fact that Superman launched the DC Extended Universe with Zack Snyder's Man of Steel, his future in the series remains grim. In Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice and Justice League, Cavill played the part twice again, to mixed reviews from viewers. To be fair, Snyder made an effort to make the character sympathetic by placing him in trying circumstances and putting him through trying times to the point where he even starts to doubt whether or not being a hero is still worthwhile (Rottentomatoes, 2016).
Critics have trashed "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice." As of this writing, the movie received a 31 % Rotten Tomatoes score, joining previous critically panned superhero movies including the 2011 "Green Lantern" movie (26 %) and the "Fantastic Four" reboot (9 %). According to one critic, spectators would leave the theatre feeling "tired and dejected”. Fans may or may not be persuaded that the confrontation between the strongest heroes from DC Comics is a spectacle worth missing. Online rage has been directed towards critics who have criticized the movie, with enraged viewers mocking their assessments, their writing, and even their motivations. While some analysts believe that the superhero movie's era of dominance in theatres is coming to an end, other movies in the category continue to appeal to viewers (Lincoln, 2016).
On the other hand, after many premieres, exclusive screenings, and screenings at Cinema on, "Captain America: Civil War" got excellent reviews for months. The primary justification given by many detractors is that "Civil War" achieves everything well that "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice" did incorrectly. They both had a lot happening on at once and comparable narrative lines, but Marvel executed the idea better given additional unique components like comedy and great feats. Some of the reasons are (Reyes, 2016)–
The more exciting and engaging movie is "Civil War," which is hardly unexpected given how successfully Disney has steered the Marvel Comics Universe to supremacy on the big screen. When it's not poking fun of its own excesses in films like "Dead pool," which engages in meta-snark exercises, "Civil War" injects doses of much-needed joy into a genre of filmmaking that has grown buried in dreary pretentiousness. Whereas, the Batman V. Superman was full of dark actions and humor that was not enough to keep the audience engaged.
'Captain America: Civil War' ultimately works its will on audience, dragging them down with the weight of its self-importance as much as anything else. On the other side, as has become standard with Marvel movies, the earth-shattering action stunts are the best money can buy. The stunts in Batman V. Superman were also good.
Marvel's Captain America: Civil War "gets right everything that Batman v Superman went wrong, from colour scheme to staging violent battle sequences to sprinkling lots of moments of sheer pleasure and delight throughout the two and a half hour running time”. Even though it deals with important subjects (such as private individuals giving over authority to the government), "Captain America: Civil War" is so entertaining that, unlike "Batman v Superman," the film's extended running time seems to go by quickly (Verhoeven, 2016).
DC Comics enthusiasts paid to view a teaser presentation in IMAX months ago because they were eager to watch the first footage from Zack Snyder's Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice. After recording an introduction and playing the trailer twice, the filmmaker cut to a quick scene of Superman (Henry Cavill) and Batman (Ben Affleck), who were about to engage in combat. As of this writing, Civil War has a Rotten Tomatoes score of 91 percent, which is 63 percentage points greater than that of Marvel's previous rival from DC Comics, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice.
It would be an understatement to say that most of the reviews for Zack Snyder's most recent blockbuster, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, have been unfavourable. Snyder and the whole ensemble of the movie took turns addressing the criticisms that critics had of the movie in an interview with Yahoo UK. The intriguing part is that these critics have their own personal beliefs, and personal opinions always have a source, according to Cavill. The angry, tough-minded vigilante from The Dark Knight Returns was not what the Batman v Superman fans wanted, according to director Zack Snyder (Bromwich, 2016).
Because Batman v Superman is an obviously political film and never tries to conceal it, many people dislike it. Each action on this Planet is a political act, as the movie explicitly explains, and it adheres to that tenet. But when individuals claim that they "don't like politics in movies," they frequently mean that they dislike a certain kind of politics. With its politically charged moral message opposing the process of dehumanization, Batman v Superman is fairly unambiguous. Batman's racism is revealed to have sprung from a feeling of helplessness and would ultimately lead him to become everything he genuinely despises. Superman is presented as the ultimate manifestation of Otherness (Tassi, 2016).
The discussion was about screening, context, themes, critics and audience response of movie Batman V. Superman of Snyder and Captain America – Civil Wars of Russo Brothers. Although the theme of the story is same i.e. fight between the group of two team of superheroes. Both Snyder and Russos put great efforts in making the protagonist to be the heroes of their respective movies. However, Captain America-Civil War found to be more interesting by the Critics and audience than the Batman V. Superman.
Bromwich, J. E. (2016). ‘Batman v Superman’ Battles the Critics. The New York Times.
Hughes, M. (2016). Review: 'Batman V Superman' Triumphant. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/markhughes/2016/03/22/review-batman-v-superman-triumphant/?sh=17d1c5445b26
Hughes, M. (2016). Zack Snyder Loves Superman, And 'Batman V Superman' Proves It. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/markhughes/2016/03/29/zack-snyder-loves-superman-and-batman-v-superman-proves-it/?sh=7f8e3e30c64b
Lincoln, K. (2016). On Batman v Superman v Critics v Audiences, and the Modern Idea of Movie Success. New York - Vulture . https://www.vulture.com/2016/03/decoding-batman-v-supermans-complex-reception.html
Mendelson, S. (2016). Why 'Batman V Superman' Was A Lesser Box Office Draw Than 'Captain America: Civil War'. Forbes. forbes.com/sites/scottmendelson/2016/05/10/why-batman-v-superman-was-always-going-to-lose-to-captain-america-civil-war/?sh=29ebb26b5d5d
Reyes, J. (2016). Critics Are Calling Captain America: Civil War Marvel’s Best Movie Yet. New York - Vulture. https://www.vulture.com/2016/04/captain-america-civil-war-review-roundup.html
Rottentomatoes. (2016). Retrieved from https://www.rottentomatoes.com/: https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/batman_v_superman_dawn_of_justice
Schilling, D. (2016). Every single thing that is wrong with Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/mar/25/review-batman-v-superman-dawn-of-justice
Schilling, D. (2016). Why Captain America: Civil War is better than Batman v Superman. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/may/07/captain-america-civil-war-better-than-batman-v-superman
Tassi, P. (2016). 'Captain America: Civil War' Shows Exactly Why 'Batman V. Superman' Failed. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2016/05/09/captain-america-civil-war-shows-exactly-why-batman-v-superman-failed/?sh=59487a2110d0
Verhoeven, B. (2016). 7 Reasons Critics Love ‘Captain America: Civil War’. The Wrap. https://www.thewrap.com/captain-america-civil-war-reviews-7-reasons-critics-love-marvel-disney-movie-chris-evans-iron-man/
You Might Also Like:-
Making Healthy Public Policy Assignment Sample
Explore The Best Medical Science Research Topics
Get 24x7 instant assistance whenever you need.
Get affordable prices for your every assignment.
Assure you to deliver the assignment before the deadline
Get Plagiarism and AI content free Assignment
Get direct communication with experts immediately.
Get
500 Words Free
on your assignment today
It's Time To Find The Right Expert to Prepare Your Assignment!
Do not let assignment submission deadlines stress you out. Explore our professional assignment writing services with competitive rates today!
Secure Your Assignment!
+61 480 015 851